Charles David Thompson

Attorney at Law

Too Many Jurors On Houston Case

February 11, 2009 By Charles Thompson

 

13th juror prompts mistrial in murder case

 

Assocaited Press

 

HOUSTON — Usually, the trouble is not finding enough jurors. In Harris County, it was one too many.

State District Judge Mark Kent Ellis had to declare a mistrial Tuesday in a murder trial after an extra juror was allowed to deliberate.

Criminal juries must have only 12 members. Ellis said the 13th juror would be considered outside influence even though she sat through all of the testimony.

"In 23 years I’ve never seen anything like this," Ellis said.  "The jurors all seemed pretty upset, but there’s no way to unring that bell."

The judge blamed a substitute bailiff.

"I told him I never want to see him in my courtroom again," Ellis said.

Juror Paula Harlan said the extra juror tried to leave, but the bailiff said she needed to complete paperwork that was never brought to her.

"It was a weird deal," Harlan said.

Filed Under: Courts

IF YOU NEED A DEFENSE ATTORNEY, CONTACT OUR OFFICE NOW USING THE FORM BELOW

Contact Form

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Home
  • Attorney Charles Thompson
  • DWI (Driving While Intoxicated)
  • Juvenile Crime Defense
  • Weapons Charge Defense
  • Other Areas of Practice
  • Office Locations
  • If You Are Arrested
  • Helpful Links
  • Harris County Criminal Courts
  • About Board Certification
  • Blog
  • Recent Cases
Free Case Evaluation
Call 713.668.5700

We Accept


Principal Office in Houston, TX




Voted as a Top Criminal Lawyer in Houston by H Texas Magazine in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014
Copyright © 2025 Charles David Thompson, Attorney at Law · All Rights Reserved Website Developement by Levy Marketing Group